1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Reggie McNeal

Discussion in 'Sooner Football' started by tbl, Jan 8, 2006.


  1. tbl

    tbl SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    Up until late this season, all the experts said McNeal was the better QB between he and Young. Now everybody thinks VY is the greatest athlete that has ever lived. Will McNeal still go in the first round or is he completely overshadowed by Vance?
     
  2. sas

    sas New Member

    Reggie won't be a first rounder IMO.

    The rap on him(that I hear) is that he's dumb and only survives by pure talent. Makes it tough for the NFL.
     
  3. Big Red Ron

    Big Red Ron SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    mcneal is a whiney little quiter and will probably never be an nfl qb.
     
  4. sas

    sas New Member

    He'll get about the same opportunity that Michael Bishop did.

    Slightly smarter. Less talent. About even.
     
  5. Widescreen

    Widescreen SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    With McNeal's unique skills, he'll likely end up in either the housekeeping or food service industries.
     
  6. AustinTXHorn

    AustinTXHorn 'Spek, out.

    Any team that drafts McNeal anywhere early or as a QB would be stupid. Anybody who sits out the big rivalry game, last game of his collegiate career, and a game that determines bowl eligibility after being cleared to play by doctors just so they can stay healthy for the combines is not a team player that isn't fit to lead any NFL team.

    He's faster than Vince Young and probably has a stronger arm. But he's not as smart, not the leader, not as good of a runner, and not as good of a passer. In his years at Texas, Vince learned and was able to get better each year. McNeal didn't get much better.
     
  7. HuskerPower

    HuskerPower New Member

    I think the SI curse struck again...

    [​IMG]
     
  8. OU_Sooners75

    OU_Sooners75 SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    can McNeal articulate a sentence better than Vince Young?
     
    CrimsonJim likes this.
  9. sas

    sas New Member

    aks him a question and see
     
  10. bluedogok

    bluedogok SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    OH CANADA!!!!!
     
  11. jreed13

    jreed13 SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    McNeil was never a 1st rounder. He is a pothead
     
  12. NYaggie

    NYaggie New Member

    That's what they said about Ja'mar Toooooooooooommmmbbbbbs. And like Toombs, I doubt he'll be a 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th, or 7th rounder.

    McNeal is a selfish player, documented time and again. The teams he got dealt with generally sucked, and that is not his fault. But you could tell the players ralllied around Stephen McGee late in the season.
     
  13. jreed13

    jreed13 SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    That being said, he is an amazing athlete and had tremendous upside...
     
  14. AFL, CFL, or world league QB at best.....lean towards the AFL...
     
  15. 12

    12 SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    Are you absolutely positive that was the reason he didn't suit up?
    ;)
     
  16. mrowl

    mrowl SoonerFans.com Elite Member

    McNeal is a 2nd day guy.
     
  17. jreed13

    jreed13 SoonerFans.com Elite Member


    COUGH (the fake roy williams) COUGH ;)
     

Share This Page