Nations best QB rankings

[w0lfe]

4 of the top 10 in Big 12

http://www.newerascouting.com/08/the-best-25-qbs-in-college-football/

Rank QB
1 Sam Bradford OU Jr
2 Colt McCoy Texas Sr
3 Jevan Snead Ole Miss Sr
4 Tim Tebow Florida Sr
5 Robert Griffin Baylor So
6 Zac Robinson OKState Sr
7 Dan LeFevour C Mich Sr
8 Jake Locker Wash. Jr
9 Russell Wilson NCState So
10 Aaron Corp USC So
11 Case Keenum Houston Jr
12 Daryll Clark Penn State Sr
13 Jeremiah Masoli Oregon Jr
14 Kellen Moore Boise State So
15 Terrelle Pryor Ohio State So
16 Jimmy Clausen ND Jr
17 Max Hall BYU Sr
18 Colin Kaepernick Nevada Jr
19 Tim Hiller W Mich Sr
20 Todd Reesing KU Sr
21 Juice Williams Illinois Sr
22 Tony Pike Cincinnati Sr
23 Matt Grothe USF Sr
24 Trevor Vittattoe UTEP Jr
25 Riley Skinner WF Sr

[JLEW1818]

I'd rather have Ressing then Griffin

[stoops the eternal pimp]

I'd rather have Robinson than Griffin

Im interested to see what Jake Locker does this season..seems everybody that has seen him during the offseason is pretty impressed with his improvement

[JLEW1818]

my buddy thought he was going to be the **** last year........ whoops!

[stoops the eternal pimp]

I dont see a whole lot of future NFL star power on that list...

[SoonersEnFuego]

Yeah, Griffin is waaaaaaaaaay too high.

[JLEW1818]

I love watching Russell Wilson

[w0lfe]

Im interested to see what Jake Locker does this season..seems everybody that has seen him during the offseason is pretty impressed with his improvement

He was lighting my depleted Syracuse defense up in NCAA 10, and then i took his knees out =]

But yea, I was surprised that Aaron Corp is even that highly ranked

[Widescreen]

I'd rather have Robinson than Griffin


For the guaranteed goal-line fumbles? :D

[SoonersBIG7]

how can you rate a quarterback in the top ten that hasn't taken a snap as a starter yet? (aaron corp) I think if you load griffin with the talent that other players have they have in the right spot, but he doesn't.

[NormanPride]

Everyone always says that with the scramblers, but when they go to the NFL they suck.

[JLEW1818]

i hate scramblers, everything about them

[LawtonBoy74]

I dont see a whole lot of future NFL star power on that list...

I dont see how you can say that, just with Bradford on the list is enough...and theres alot of other guys on the list with NFL star power potential.. just because your not the top QB in college doesnt mean you wont be good in the NFL...Tom Brady anyone???

[freshchris05]

I love watching Russell Wilson

yeah i saw a couple ncstate games last year and was impressed myself...

[JLEW1818]

I dont see how you can say that, just with Bradford on the list is enough...and theres alot of other guys on the list with NFL star power potential.. just because your not the top QB in college doesnt mean you wont be good in the NFL...Tom Brady anyone???

Tom Brady's don't happen much

[sooner518]

can we please hold a press conference to figure out who is to blame for Jevan Snead being above Tim Tebow?

[SbOrOiNaEnR]

how can you rate a quarterback in the top ten that hasn't taken a snap as a starter yet? (aaron corp)

^ This

[GottaHavePride]

can we please hold a press conference to figure out who is to blame for Jevan Snead being above Tim Tebow?

Steve Spurrier.

[SoonerLB]

Glad Sam is where he belongs on that list!
I know Todd Reesing isn't considered highly as a pro QB, but I'd take him over Jimmy Clausen any day! And why Aaron Corp is in the mix is beyond me!

[sooner ngintunr]

I'd rather have Ressing then Griffin


I'd rather have Robinson than Griffin



heh, he'll have a better soph year than those two schmoes did.

:pop:

[IronSooner]

Glad Sam is where he belongs on that list!
I know Todd Reesing isn't considered highly as a pro QB, but I'd take him over Jimmy Clausen any day! And why Aaron Corp is in the mix is beyond me!

I was about to ask exactly what they're basing Aaron Corp's inclusion on. Recruiting stars?

Same goes for Jimmy Clausen. Really?

[stoops the eternal pimp]

I dont see how you can say that, just with Bradford on the list is enough...and theres alot of other guys on the list with NFL star power potential.. just because your not the top QB in college doesnt mean you wont be good in the NFL...Tom Brady anyone???

Right, because Tom Brady is the rule, not the exception:rolleyes:

[stoops the eternal pimp]

heh, he'll have a better soph year than those two schmoes did.

:pop:

robinson threw for over 3000 and rushed for over 500....i think he did ok

[BoulderSooner79]

With 5 star recruits at all the OL positions as well as WR, any USC QB just has to close his eyes and throw to get a > 50% completion rate. I hear Aaron Corp is going to play with eyes open.

[SoonerAficionadOU]

just because your not the top QB in college doesnt mean you wont be good in the NFL...Tom Brady anyone???
And just because you're a great college QB apparently doesn't mean you'll do well in the NFL...Vince Young anyone? (http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/spt/columnists/jtaylor/stories/082409dnspotaylorcol.33da293.html)

(Woulda posted this in another thread but I can't create new ones yet, and it was vaguely related :-p)

[JLEW1818]

many many many people thought Vince would be nothing in the NFL, myself included.

[LawtonBoy74]

Tom is the exception I guess, but there are a lot of other QBs who werent hot shots in college like Tony Romo, Big Ben he was good in college but no one thought he'd win two superbowls....The QB position is one of the hardest positions to scout because some guys like Vince Young had a great Texas team to play for in college where he could depend on his athleticism.. and then you have guys like Big Ben and Eli Manning who were on above average college teams but then made the transition to the NFL in great situations where they didn't have to win games with their arm but they could depend on their great running backs and offensive schemes.

[w0lfe]

Yeah, Jimmy Clausen is an abosolute joke along with his coach

[JLEW1818]

Ben was still a first rounder, that went late in the first round, therefore the team drafting him, is usually pretty good.

[stoops the eternal pimp]

Ben was still a first rounder, that went late in the first round, therefore the team drafting him, is usually pretty good.

ben went number 11...

[JLEW1818]

dang, didn't somebody go later then him in the first round? think the bills?

[stoops the eternal pimp]

jp losman?

[JLEW1818]

yah, i was thinking the Steelers had that pick for some reason... anyway lets compare 04, and 06

Manning
Rivers
Roethlisberger


Young
Leinart
Cutler



HAHA!

[LawtonBoy74]

Ryan Leaf, Tim Couch, David Carr???

[ouleaf]

If that list is based on NFL potential, how can you put Tebow that high?

[badger]

Im interested to see what Jake Locker does this season..seems everybody that has seen him during the offseason is pretty impressed with his improvement

Does Jake Locker still have a neck?

I'm not just referring to our game... dude has gotten twisted so many times that his neck must be made of taffy.
http://jenkinsfamilyblog.files.wordpress.com/2008/11/jake-locker.jpg

[VA Sooner]

Jevan Sneed above Tim Tebow.

I can see Ole Miss winning their division and playing Florida in the SEC title game. We'll see who earns their ranking.

And with their tie-breaker system, could keep the SEC out of a title game. Which is why the Big 12 coaches voted to keep the current tie-breaker system in place.

Didn't Arkansas fire the current Ole Miss coach?

[sooner ngintunr]

robinson threw for over 3000 and rushed for over 500....i think he did ok

Oh yeah, him and Reesing had very good Soph years and they are both very good QB's today.

I just think that RGIII is going to be better.:D

[CobraKai]

He was lighting my depleted Syracuse defense up in NCAA 10, and then i took his knees out =]

But yea, I was surprised that Aaron Corp is even that highly ranked

Corp was the first thing that jumped out to me. Makes no sense...

[G8trGr8t]

how can you rate a quarterback in the top ten that hasn't taken a snap as a starter yet? (aaron corp) I think if you load griffin with the talent that other players have they have in the right spot, but he doesn't.

List is absolutely bogus. Corp just got demoted and Barkeley is going to start for USC. Media is going to have a new guy to fawn over now.

Now if you want to ask some people who know something about football who they would pick as a QB, read this article.

http://www.sportingnews.com/college-football/article/2009-08-26/legends-tebow

[G8trGr8t]

If that list is based on NFL potential, how can you put Tebow that high?

read this article for your answer
http://www.sportingnews.com/college-football/article/2009-08-26/legends-tebow

[Crucifax Autumn]

That link is useless to make your point. Several pick Bradford and at least one says he'd be running the option with Tebow. That does not equate to Tebow having anything resembling pro potential.

[bent rider]

What the fetch?! Max Hall is not in the top 5? This outfit is obviously anti-Mormon!!

[A-M]

I thought that Tim T was the greatest football player around. After, the TB tells me that he can 'will' his time to win. So, why is he at #4?

[illinisooner]

Aaron Corp hasn't started or played in a game yet and he's top 10? The list says "best QB rankings", not "highest recruited QB rankings". While I don't doubt that Mr. Corp is talented, he needs to prove it on the field first. While we're on the subject of USC QB's, a true freshman QB going into Columbus at night...good luck Trojans.

[sooneron]

John Cooper? The guy who owned Mich with a 2-10-1 record? Uh, ok.

[stoops the eternal pimp]

thats what i was thinking...like cru said, that article has nothing to do with the nfl...

i think i could have found some better legends

timmy is a great college quarterback, so sure he is in a debate where they would want him to be their college starter...

[sooneron]

thats what i was thinking...like cru said, that article has nothing to do with the nfl...

i think i could have found some better legends

timmy is a great college quarterback, so sure he is in a debate where they would want him to be their college starter...

Well, there were two whole MNCs on that panel. We all know that RC knows what he's doing when it comes to the qb situation!


http://members.cox.net/norminnorman/slocninkick.jpg

props to Norm, btw..

[Clever Trevor]

I'd take Snead over all of them.

[Jacie]

4 of the top 10 in Big 12

http://www.newerascouting.com/08/the-best-25-qbs-in-college-football/

Rank QB
1 Sam Bradford OU Jr
2 Colt McCoy Texas Sr
3 Jevan Snead Ole Miss Sr
4 Tim Tebow Florida Sr
5 Robert Griffin Baylor So
6 Zac Robinson OKState Sr
7 Dan LeFevour C Mich Sr
8 Jake Locker Wash. Jr
9 Russell Wilson NCState So
10 Aaron Corp USC So
11 Case Keenum Houston Jr
12 Daryll Clark Penn State Sr
13 Jeremiah Masoli Oregon Jr
14 Kellen Moore Boise State So
15 Terrelle Pryor Ohio State So
16 Jimmy Clausen ND Jr
17 Max Hall BYU Sr
18 Colin Kaepernick Nevada Jr
19 Tim Hiller W Mich Sr
20 Todd Reesing KU Sr
21 Juice Williams Illinois Sr
22 Tony Pike Cincinnati Sr
23 Matt Grothe USF Sr
24 Trevor Vittattoe UTEP Jr
25 Riley Skinner WF Sr

USC must be so stocked with REALLY GOOD ATHLETES that the 10th best quarterback is second string on his own team.


http://www.soonerfans.com/forums/showthread.php?t=133602